discuss this

So I’m in two classes this semester that require me to post to a CMS-style discussion board. One class requires that I post 3 “items” a week; the other asks that students answer a specific question every two weeks. For the class that requires 3 postings, we’ve been told that it’s really a “space for students” that the professor won’t engage in or really even look at much, if at all – although participation apparently does make up a part of our grade. On the face of it, that sounds pretty good, right? “A space for students,” how pedagogically sound, how constructivist even! A place for students to explore their own knowledge, to collaborate with others!

Needless to say, I haven’t posted often to that board, and I’ll tell you the reason that occured to me this morning. Each week, in addition to the discussion assignment, we’re assigned to read 4 lengthy, often dense, articles, and write a short paper on the reading in the form of a research proposal. And I have 3 other classes to prepare for as well, on top of all of the other things that this way overcommitted grad student has gotten herself into. But I’ll tell ya what. I think the biggest reason that I’m not posting isn’t the time committment in and of itself; it’s that in the context of this classroom, books and lectures are still seen as the primary, most important mode of learning, as evidenced by the proportion of time spent on that as opposed to discussion (online or offline). Learning in this mode is a solitary endeavor, all too familiar from years and years of learning from books and lectures. If this prof really wanted us to spend time on the discussion board, I think 2 things would have to change: 1) he’d have to balance it out with the other assignments in terms of time, which would entail 2) valuing the discussion board component and collaborative knowledge building as much as the books and lecture component. And there’s the issue, of course; belief structures a devil to change. I know this is pretty much old hat to a lot of people – well, duh, Sarah! I hear the 3 people who read this blog saying – but it’s enlightening when these themes connect to personal experience. Really drives it home, like Ortiz for the Red Sox last night. (sorry, couldn’t help it. Go Sox!)


1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “discuss this

  1. Ditto!
    I have one class on Online Social Interactions that effectively utilizes online blogs. It doesn’t lead to an abundance of online discussions, but the discussions that arise, either online or f2f, are extremely beneficial.
    But I have another class which sounds like yours but with an additional major group project. We are having to do a complete qualitative analysis of our department, plus all the of the long, heavy readings, plus all the standard quizzes, midterms, and papers, plus online discussions for EACH reading. That’s close to 50 online discussions alone! Every single student in the class is behind in something, there’s just no way to keep up. And it’s not like any of us are slackers, you simply don’t make it to a doctoral program unless you’re an overachiever. I’ve managed to keep up with everything but the online discussions. But if I’m going to get behind, then it’s going to be in the area that adds the least. And quite frankly, our online discussions add nothing to my understanding of the texts or the class.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s